1. Home
  2. Case Studies
  3. Seaside Assisted Living

Senior care — Hallandale Beach

Case Study: How "We Are Paid Search" Outperformed “Lead Aggregators” and “Field Marketer Referral Partners” FMRP, in Senior Care Marketing

Senior care, Seaside Hallandale Beach (YMP Senior Living)

  • 60 leads, 15 move-insWe Are Paid Search in 2024 — a 25.00% conversion rate
  • 225 leads, 1 move-inLead aggregators — a 0.44% conversion rate
  • 29 leads, 11 move-insField Marketer Referral Partners — a 37.93% conversion rate

Driving Superior Move-in Rates: "We Are Paid Search" vs. “Lead Aggregators” and “Field Marketer Referral Partners”

Introduction

In the highly competitive senior care market, acquiring high-quality leads that convert into actual move-ins is crucial for success. Senior care communities often rely on multiple lead generation sources, including digital marketing agencies, lead aggregators (like A Place for Mom or Caring.com), and referral partners (such as hospitals or doctors).

This case study highlights how "We Are Paid Search" consistently outperformed both lead aggregators and Field Marketer referral partners in generating leads and converting those leads into move-ins for Seaside Hallandale Beach.

Objective

The purpose of this analysis is to evaluate the effectiveness of different lead sources—We Are Paid Search, Lead Aggregators, and Field Marketer Referral Partners—in driving leads and converting them into residents. The focus is on conversion rates (leads to move-ins) and the overall impact on senior care communities.

Methodology

Data was collected from Seaside Hallandale Beach across 12 months (August 2023 to August 2024), tracking key performance indicators:

  • Leads Generated: The total number of leads generated by each source.
  • Move-ins: The number of leads that converted into actual move-ins (residents).
  • Conversion Rates: The percentage of leads that turned into move-ins, indicating the quality of the leads.

Key Findings

The data shows that We Are Paid Search provided superior performance in both lead quality and move-ins compared to traditional lead aggregators and referral partners.

Performance Breakdown

MetricWe Are Paid SearchLead AggregatorsFMRP’s
Total Leads (2024)6022529
Total Move-ins (2024)15111
Conversion Rate25.00%0.44%37.93%

1. Lead Generation

Over the course of 2024, We Are Paid Search generated 60 high-quality leads, significantly fewer than the 225 leads generated by lead aggregators. However, lead quality—not quantity—makes the difference in move-ins.

  • Example: In August 2024, We Are Paid Search produced 9 leads, while lead aggregators generated 31. Despite the larger number of leads from the aggregators, only We Are Paid Search and referral partners contributed to actual move-ins.

2. Conversion Rates

The most compelling aspect of the case study is the conversion rate, which clearly demonstrates the superiority of We Are Paid Search. With a 25% conversion rate, "We Are Paid Search" far outperformed lead aggregators, who struggled with an abysmal 0.44% conversion rate. Even referral partners, with a 37.93% conversion rate, couldn't scale to the level of We Are Paid Search's consistent lead-to-move-in efficiency.

  • Example: In July 2024, We Are Paid Search generated 11 leads and converted 4 into move-ins (36.36%). Meanwhile, lead aggregators generated 30 leads but achieved zero move-ins, demonstrating the significant disparity in lead quality and overall effectiveness.

3. Move-ins

Out of the 60 leads generated by We Are Paid Search in 2024, 15 resulted in move-ins, showcasing the high intent and quality of these leads. In stark contrast, lead aggregators only managed 1 move-in from 225 leads, revealing their inefficiency and lower lead quality.

Filed Marketer Referral Partners, although generating fewer leads (29), achieved 11 move-ins, showing good performance in conversion rates but still not matching the scale or reach of We Are Paid Search.

Case Example: Seaside Hallandale Beach - August 2024

  • We Are Paid Search: 9 leads, 2 move-ins (22.22% conversion rate).
  • Lead Aggregators: 31 leads, 0 move-ins.
  • Field Marketer Referral Partners: 4 leads, 1 move-in (25% conversion rate).

Conclusion

The data from Seaside Hallandale Beach clearly demonstrates that We Are Paid Search not only generated high-quality leads but also delivered a far superior conversion rate compared to traditional lead aggregators and even referral partners. The 25% conversion rate achieved by We Are Paid Search greatly surpasses the 0.44% conversion rate of lead aggregators, proving that digital marketing strategies focused on targeted, intent-driven leads outperform generic lead generation platforms.

Senior care communities relying on lead aggregators are missing out on significant move-in opportunities. By switching to We Are Paid Search, communities can dramatically improve their lead-to-move-in ratio, reduce wasteful spending on low-quality leads, and ultimately increase occupancy rates more efficiently.

Key Takeaways

  • We Are Paid Search delivers superior move-in rates, making it a more cost-effective and reliable lead generation partner.
  • Lead aggregators produce a large volume of low-quality leads, resulting in very few conversions to move-ins.
  • Referral partners, while effective, do not scale as efficiently as We Are Paid Search for long-term growth in senior care marketing.

For senior care communities seeking to boost their occupancy rates and drive predictable growth, We Are Paid Search offers a proven solution that consistently outperforms all lead aggregators and field marketer referral partner networks in the senior care space.

Listed on the We Are Paid Search Case Studies page. Original PDF: published file (also hosted here). Wording is presented as published. “We Are Paid Search” is the agency named in the original case study; these results are not attributed to Performance Ad Partners.

Want this kind of growth for your brand?

These results come from George Dahir Jr.’s client work at We Are Paid Search. Performance Ad Partners brings the same senior, hands-on approach to e-commerce brands and growing businesses as a fractional partner.

Let's Talk